What is Statistical Finality?

Statistical finality is mathematical certainty that your transaction is permanently recorded on the blockchain (assuming no 51% attack occurs). Key Insight: In Quai Network, zone chain transactions can achieve statistical finality independently of prime chain confirmations. This is revolutionary. Traditional Systems:
  • Zone transaction occurs
  • Must wait for prime chain confirmation
  • Uncertainty period = minutes to hours
Quai PoEM System:
  • Zone transaction occurs
  • Achieves finality through entropy accumulation
  • Certainty period = seconds

Why Independence Matters

The Problem with Dependencies:
  • If zone finality depends on prime blocks, attackers can target prime chains
  • Withholding a single prime block affects thousands of zone transactions
  • Creates systemic vulnerability
PoEM’s Solution:
  • Zone chains accumulate entropy faster than any single prime block can provide
  • Even the “luckiest” prime block can’t overcome zone chain entropy accumulation
  • Each zone operates with autonomous security

The Math: Maximum Withholding Attack Duration

The Question: What’s the longest time an attacker could delay finality by withholding a prime block? The Setup: Imagine an attacker finds the “luckiest” possible prime block - a hash with 63 leading zeros followed by a 1. This is incredibly rare and removes maximum entropy from the system. The Calculation:
Maximum Attack Duration = Hash Field Size / Zone Threshold
k < 256 / 25 = ~10 zone blocks
Real-World Numbers:
  • Zone block time: 10 seconds
  • Maximum attack duration: 10 blocks × 10 seconds = 100 seconds
  • Typical finality: 1 block × 10 seconds = 10 seconds
What This Means: Even with the most extreme possible luck, an attacker can only delay finality by about 100 seconds. In practice, most withholding attacks would be much shorter because finding such a “perfect” block is astronomically unlikely.

Why Attacks Are Even Shorter in Practice

Perfect Storm Requirements: The 100-second maximum assumes the attacker gets extremely lucky AND zone blocks are extremely unlucky:
  • Attacker luck: Finds a near-perfect prime block (1 in trillions chance)
  • Zone unluckiness: Zone blocks remove minimum entropy for 10 consecutive blocks
Reality Check:
  • Zone blocks typically exceed minimum entropy requirements
  • This further shortens any possible attack duration
  • Most withholding attempts would fail within 1-2 zone blocks

The Bottom Line: Geometric vs Linear Security

Traditional PoW (Linear):
  • Work accumulates by addition: 10 + 10 + 10 = 30
  • Single powerful block can overcome multiple weak blocks
  • Enables longer withholding attacks
PoEM (Geometric):
  • Entropy accumulates by multiplication: 1/1000 × 1/1000 × 1/1000 = 1/billion
  • Multiple blocks quickly become impossible to overcome
  • Practically eliminates withholding attacks

Extreme Rarity of Successful Attacks

Statistical Reality: Only 1 in 2^40 blocks (about 1 trillion) removes enough entropy to enable even a single-block withholding attack. Time Scale: With 10-second zone blocks, this means successful single-block withholding attacks occur approximately once every 350,000 years. Practical Security: For everyday users, withholding attacks are not a meaningful concern. Your transaction finality is mathematically guaranteed within seconds, regardless of what attackers attempt.
Key Takeaway: PoEM’s geometric entropy accumulation makes withholding attacks not just impractical, but mathematically negligible for real-world use.